“Law & Order: Special Victims Unit” (SVU) has been a staple of television since its debut in 1999. At the heart of its success is the iconic character, Olivia Benson, portrayed by Mariska Hargitay. But did you know that before Hargitay secured the role, several other actresses were in the running? This article explores the top contenders who almost became the face of SVU and how the show could have looked very different.

The Search for Olivia Benson

Casting a lead character for a long-running show is no easy feat. NBC and SVU creator Dick Wolf knew they needed someone with depth, charisma, and strength to bring the role of Olivia Benson to life. Several actresses auditioned for the role, and some even came very close to landing it. Let’s take a look at the names that were in contention.

The Almost-Olivias: Actresses Who Came Close

1. Samantha Mathis

Samantha Mathis, known for films like Pump Up the Volume and American Psycho, was reportedly one of the top contenders. Her mix of toughness and vulnerability made her a strong choice, but ultimately, the producers went in another direction.

2. Reiko Aylesworth

Best known for her role as Michelle Dessler on 24, Aylesworth was another name heavily considered. Her ability to portray a no-nonsense law enforcement officer made her an ideal candidate, but she didn’t make the final cut.

3. Jeri Ryan

Before she joined Boston Public and Star Trek: Voyager, Jeri Ryan was considered for Olivia Benson. While her striking screen presence was undeniable, she ultimately didn’t fit the vision the producers had for the role.

4. Connie Nielsen

Connie Nielsen, famous for her role in Gladiator, was rumored to be in the mix. Though she would later appear on SVU as a temporary replacement for Hargitay, she was never officially cast as Benson.

5. Melina Kanakaredes

Before starring in CSI: NY, Kanakaredes was reportedly approached for Olivia Benson. However, scheduling conflicts and other commitments prevented her from taking on the role.

Why Mariska Hargitay Was the Perfect Choice

1. Authenticity and Dedication

From the moment Hargitay auditioned, she embodied Olivia Benson. Her natural chemistry with Christopher Meloni (Elliot Stabler) sealed the deal.

2. The Right Balance of Strength and Compassion

Benson needed to be tough but also empathetic. Hargitay brought the perfect mix, making her character both a fierce detective and a relatable hero.

3. Unmatched Longevity and Evolution

Over the years, Hargitay’s Benson evolved from a passionate detective to a strong leader, proving she was the right choice from the beginning.

How SVU Would Have Been Different with Another Actress

Had any of the other actresses landed the role, SVU could have had a completely different feel. Some might have leaned into a colder, more analytical portrayal, while others may not have had the same longevity and impact as Hargitay.

Conclusion

Mariska Hargitay wasn’t the only actress considered for Olivia Benson, but she was undoubtedly the best choice. Her performance has helped Law & Order: SVU become one of the longest-running shows in television history. While it’s fun to imagine what could have been, it’s hard to picture anyone else in the role that Hargitay has made legendary.